The Question
Some people believe that private schools provide a better education than state schools. Others disagree. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
How to approach this question
Dedicate one body paragraph to each view, presenting the strongest version of each argument fairly. Then give your own opinion - either as a brief conclusion or by integrating it into your final paragraph.
The question of whether private schools provide superior education to state schools is both empirically contested and politically charged, touching on deep questions about social mobility, opportunity, and the proper role of markets in education.
Proponents of private schools point to their academic outcomes, which in most countries exceed state school averages on examination results and university admission rates. Smaller class sizes, more experienced staff retained through higher salaries, superior facilities, and extensive extracurricular provision combine to create a richer educational environment. Advocates also argue that parental choice is a legitimate freedom in a liberal society, and that competition from private schools creates performance incentives for state schools to improve.
However, critics argue persuasively that comparing raw academic outcomes between private and state schools conflates the effect of schooling with the effect of socioeconomic selection. Private schools draw overwhelmingly from affluent families whose children arrive with greater cultural capital, nutritional security, and academic support at home. When researchers control for these background advantages, the performance differential attributed to private schooling narrows substantially. More critically, the existence of private schools actively harms state education by drawing motivated families, engaged parents, and experienced teachers away from the public system, concentrating disadvantage in the schools that serve the most vulnerable children.
My view is that private schools perform better in part because they select advantaged students, and in part because they receive more resources. Both factors perpetuate social stratification rather than reward genuine educational quality. Societies serious about providing equal opportunity would channel private school resources and teacher talent into a comprehensive, well-funded state system rather than accepting parallel provision as inevitable.
272+ words · Targets Band 7.5
Now write your own answer
Reading a sample answer improves your awareness. Writing one yourself - then getting AI feedback on all four marking criteria - is what actually moves your band score.
Practice Writing Task 2 →In some countries, governments fund university education so that everyone who qualifies can attend without paying tuition fees. Do the advantages of this policy outweigh the disadvantages?
EducationSome people argue that university students should pay all of the costs of their education because they are the primary beneficiaries of their degrees. Others believe education should be subsidised or funded by the state. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
EducationSome parents choose to educate their children at home rather than sending them to school. What are the advantages and disadvantages of homeschooling?